If you’re just beginning the journey of choosing custom cabinets for your home, you’re certain to face the dilemma that all new cabinet purchasers must confront: whether to have your new cabinets painted or stained. It’s one of the most important decisions you’ll make, as your choice of cabinet colors and stains will impact the overall tone and atmosphere of the space.

Both stained cabinets and painted cabinets can produce a wonderful visual appeal and the desired effect, but their look and performance are decidedly different. Here are some of the factors to consider when deciding between the two.

Painted or Stained Cabinets? The Pros and Cons of Each

Stained Cabinets

Pros

  • Showcases the natural wood grain
    Hardwood cabinets can show off their inherent beauty with a stained finish, especially with lighter stains, which highlight the natural knots, lines and textures that are perfect for a warm, traditional look.
  • Easy damage touch-up
    Hiding small dings and scratches is much easier with a stained surface.
  • Less expensive than painted cabinetry
    Choosing a stained finish for your hardwood or wood veneer cabinets is more affordable than having them painted, as the stains are less expensive.
  • Longer lasting than painted cabinets
    Since the stain penetrates and becomes part of the surface of the wood, stained cabinets can last for decades with the proper care.

Cons

  • More difficult to hide major damage
    Large dents or scratches can’t be hidden well on stained surfaces, because staining over them will just make them more noticeable.
  • Require more cleaning
    Dust and dirt are easier to see, especially on darker stains, meaning more dusting and maintenance.

Painted Cabinets

Pros

  • Wide variety of color choices
    Cabinets can be painted in any color desired, giving you much more flexibility in setting the feel and atmosphere of a room. They offer a smooth and uniform look that can range from bright and cheerful to dark and contemplative, from modern to retro.
  • Easier to clean and maintain
    Although dirt and smudges show up more on painted surfaces, they’re much easier to clean off than on stained cabinets.
  • Simpler to do color changes
    Painted cabinets can simply be repainted for a change of decor, while stained cabinets need to be sanded and restained.

Cons

  • More prone to blemishes
    Paint is more susceptible to chipping, peeling, and showing wear over time, requiring more frequent touch-ups or repainting.
  • More expensive
    Painted cabinets are typically 10-15% more expensive than stained cabinets due to the additional labor involved in the painting process.

Overall, painted cabinets offer a wider range of color options for a more contemporary look, while stained cabinets provide a timeless, natural wood aesthetic. Consider your style preferences, budget, and willingness to maintain the finish when making your choice.

Contact Walters Cabinets today to arrange a consultation with one of our custom cabinet professionals.